• April 17, 2021
  • Register
  • Sign in
    • Forgot Password ?
    OR
    • Sign in
  • FAQ
  • Contact
  • About us
www.cnctimes.com logo
  • Editorials
    • NEWS
    • CASE STUDIES
    • INTERVIEWS
    • SUCCESS STORY
    • PRODUCT SHOWCASE
    • TECHNICAL ARTICLES
    • BLOGS
    • VIDEOS
    • NEWSLETTERS
  • Forum
  • EVENTS
  • INVENTORY
    • INVENTORY LISTINGS
    • AUCTION LISTINGS
    • WANTED LISTINGS
  • BUSINESS LEADS
    • BUYERS
    • MANUFACTURERS
    • DEALERS
  • SHOWROOM
  • JOBS
  • Register
  • Sign in
  • Contact
  • Advertise
  • Feedback

Information

Please login to give the feedback.

Information

Please login to give the feedback.

  1. Home
  2. Technical Articles
  3. Virtual Machining

Virtual Machining

14 September, 2013
  • Tweet
  • share via email
Your comment has been posted.
We have sent you a verification email. To verify, just follow the link in the message.
Some technical error. Please try again.

By K.P. Karunakaran, R. Shringi and Amit Kumar Singh

Computer Graphics Laboratory, Department of Mechanical Engineering
Indian Institute of technology Bombay, Powai, Mumbai 400076, INDIA

Verification of NC programs through trial machining is risky, slow and costly. Virtual machining using software tools can overcome this difficulty. Optimization of cutting parameters achieved through this cuts down machining time and improves quality and tool life. But existing virtual machining methods are all inexact.

1. Introduction

The sources of errors in NC programs are many and varied. They range from relatively trivial syntax errors to subtle interactions with work-holding fixtures. Debugging NC programs on the shop floor is expensive, time consuming and sometimes dangerous. Hence, NC users and developers have sought computational aids for program development and verification from the earliest days of NC.

CAD/CAM/CAE packages available today offer total solutions to the users by incorporating modules for modeling, visualization, analysis and manufacturing. Almost all CAM modules can generate efficient NC cutter paths with minimal user interactions. Some of them are even able to generate the cutter paths automatically for simple geometries of rotary or prismatic nature. However, the correctness of the NC programs generated by these packages cannot be guaranteed until a component is produced on a CNC machine using these programs and inspected. An unproved NC program may have movements that may cause collisions with the fixture elements, dig into the component, create undercuts, gouge the component or leave excess material. An erroneous NC program may also produce out of tolerance dimensions, poor surface finish or have wasteful movements. The task of ascertaining the correctness of the NC programs of a component is called NC Verification or Tape Proving.
The physical tape proving methods have the following drawbacks:

:: They are slow and tedious.
:: The machine tool is utilized less efficiently during tape proving.
:: The programmer and operator are underutilized and fatigued.
:: These methods may be dangerous for the operator and can cause damage to the machine and cutting tools.

Efforts have been going on for a long time on two fronts to eliminate or minimize the time and money spent in tape proving. Researchers in the area of Computer Automated Part Programming (CAPP) have been trying to develop intelligent cutter path generation systems that can produce error-free NC programs thus alleviating the need for verification altogether. Such a system would require vast knowledgebase (KB) and database (DB) related to machining and fantastic computing power to scan through these in order to obtain a 'zero-defect' NC program of a practical component. Furthermore, these knowledge and data bases themselves need to be updated to keep pace with technological growth such as the development of new cutter materials, high speed machining etc.. It appears too optimistic to expect such software to be available in the near future. This prompted people to work in the development of software that would simulate the machining process virtually on a computer screen. These Virtual Machining (VM) systems emulate the CNC machines. While the graphic simulation available in most CAM packages show only motions, the VM systems can depict the material removal as well. In a VM system, one starts with the virtual model of the work piece and as machining progresses, the geometry of the work piece gets updated by subtracting the volume swept by the cutter during each motion. It is possible to model even the machine tool and fixture elements so that even collisions can be detected.

Since the user gets a realistic visual feel of the machining process in a VM system, it helps in predicting errors on the computer screen itself. This system can automatically do the verification both to ascertain the safety of machining (detection of collision etc.) and geometric conformance to design. It is also possible to optimize the technological parameters (spindle speed and feed rate) from the geometric characteristics of the material removal process.

2. Classification of NC Verification Systems

NC verification is the process of ascertaining the correctness of cutter movements before performing the actual machining. Table 1 presents the various methods used for NC verification. Any of these methods can be either an online or an offline method depending on whether the activity is carried out on the actual CNC machine or on an offline computer or a desktop CNC machine. Methods such as Z-neglect machining, scaled-down machining, dry-run machining and alternate-material machining come under this category. On the other hand, scaled-down machining, dry-run machining and alternate-material machining can be carried out offline on a separate cheaper machine. Virtual machining is obviously preferable to physical machining.

Table 1 Classification of NC Verification Methods
  On-line Off-line

Physical

Z-neglect machining
Scaled-down machining
Dry-run machining
Alternate-material machining
Desk-top manufacture

Virtual

Kinematic NC simulation
Volumetric NC simulation
Kinematic NC simulation
Volumetric NC simulation


A PC workstation costs as low as Rs. 25,000 whereas even a small 3 axis CNC machining center (of about 450mm traverse on the longest axis) from a reputed builder costs about Rs. 25,00,000, a factor of over 100. When such a CNC machine is engaged for graphic simulation, it is used at less that 1% efficiency. This is apart from the fact that the quality of graphic simulation on the CNC is inferior to that of an offline PC due to its high resolution and computing resources. Therefore, it makes more sense to do NC verification virtually on an offline PC.

Graphics-based or virtual NC simulation can be grouped into the following 2 categories:

i. Kinematic NC Simulation (KinSim)
ii. Volumetric NC Simulation (VolSim)

KinSim is very popular among CAM packages because of its low computational complexity. As the cutter moves, it is drawn at the end of each position. The cutter may be depicted simply by its tip or axis or it may be drawn fully in 2D or 3D. Some of these kinematic displays are shown in Figure 1. KinSim can depict only motions and not material removal. Therefore, physical NC verification may be necessary before releasing the NC program for regular production.

  • Follow @CNCTimes

Captcha is required.
Sorry Captcha Unsuccessful!!

Latest Technical Articles

  • 05 October, 2020

    Use of Costing and Quoting in the Metal Fabrication Industry

  • 28 January, 2020

    The Additive Update: Wilson Tools

  • 04 May, 2019

    Faster and better machining performance: on existing equipment

  • 24 April, 2019

    Convenient clamping by magnet: Schunk

  • 23 April, 2019

    The 3D FABRI GEAR Advantage

  • 19 April, 2019

    Development of Two Types of Sintering Bonding Materials for Next-generation Power Modules

  • 15 April, 2019

    60% higher productivity with Duo-Lock™

  • 03 April, 2019

    Digital Twins, The Birth of Constant Optimization: Siemens

  • 01 April, 2019

    Bridging the Skills Gap with MAZATROL

  • 22 March, 2019

    THE PRECISE GEOMETRY OF 3D CUTTING KBM motors as a byword for accuracy in laser cutting

  • 05 March, 2019

    Fire risks in a CNC

  • 19 February, 2019

    Group Technology: Operational Excellence in the Industry 4.0 Era

  • 30 June, 2018

    Robotic Fettling for Iron Castings- A revolution in the foundry industry

  • 08 May, 2018

    Collaborative Robots, India and the Future of Manufacturing

  • 13 June, 2017

    PRACTICAL APPROACH TO CONTROL WASTE IN MANUFACTURING

  • 09 June, 2017

    ESPRIT’s 2017 software update

  • 30 March, 2017

    Dexterous from SCHUNK

  • 20 March, 2017

    PiWeb from Zeiss Metrology:  Quality Data Management with Easy Reporting

  • 22 February, 2017

    How an insert is made

  • 20 February, 2017

    EW500 Industrial Router: Safe Connection for Your Industrial Applications

  • 23 January, 2017

    Taking the plunge in turning

Previous Next

Related Technical Articles

  • 03 April, 2014

    Reverse engineering and its importance in new product development

    Category: Software
  • 20 September, 2013

    Optimising Multi-axis CNC Productivity

    Category: Software
  • 14 September, 2013

    Reverse Engineering

    Category: Software
  • 14 September, 2013

    Solid Modelling vs Surface Modelling

    Category: Software

News

  • 12 April, 2021

    Strength of cold working steel

    Category: Software
  • 06 April, 2021

    Machine Swap through ESPRIT CAM

    Category: Software
  • 30 March, 2021

    IronCAD Mechanical 2021 is an add-on productivity module in the IronCAD Productivity

    Category: Software
  • 23 March, 2021

    CAMWorks releases new wire EDM module with single click model-to-G-code functionality

    Category: Software
  • 16 March, 2021

    Shapr3D moves from “Imagination to production”

    Category: Software
  • 09 March, 2021

    Mastercam Mill Developments Target a Streamlined Manufacturing Process

    Category: Software
  • 02 March, 2021

    Stock Automation by Esprit CAM

    Category: Software
  • 23 February, 2021

    Ansys Launches Moxie to Enhance System Model Validation Processes

    Category: Software
  • 23 February, 2021

    Mastercam 2022 Public Beta Released for Global Testing

    Category: Software
  • 23 February, 2021

    CADBRO 2021 - A collaborative CAD tool for all your "Design Review" needs Webinar on 26th Feb @11.30am

    Category: Software
  • 16 February, 2021

    CAMBRIO Appoints Sandeep Srivastava as Country Manager for India, South East Asia, and Middle East

    Category: Software
  • 15 February, 2021

    Powerful Selection Techniques in The New ESPRIT

    Category: Software

Case Studies

  • 16 December, 2019

    Lifting Devices Provider Cyrus Designs 20% Faster with ZW3D

    Category: Software
  • 14 February, 2019

    Zoom Technologies Chooses CADbro, a powerful 3D CAD Viewer, to Accelerate Customized Mold Production

    Category: Software
  • 23 March, 2018

    Teamcenter and NX help Avcon Controls streamline processes and optimize use of resources

    Category: Software
  • 06 March, 2018

    Harita Seating Standardizes on Altair Suite of HyperWorks™ for all CAE ApplicationsHyperWorks

    Category: Software
  • 26 December, 2017

    Swiss coffee machine manufacturer optimizes development and production with Solid Edge

    Category: Software
  • 22 December, 2017

    Addressing Design Development Challenges through Simulation Driven Platform

    Category: Software
  • 11 January, 2017

    Alphacam guides 5-Axis future for Cambridge Precision

    Category: Software
  • 30 December, 2016

    Manufacturing with a Progressive Edge

    Category: Software
  • 28 December, 2016

    Responding quickly to ship structural analysis needs with easy-to-use Femap

    Category: Software
  • 27 December, 2016

    It’s all in the family

    Category: Software
  • 19 December, 2016

    Manufacturing speed for Drag Boats

    Category: Software
  • 12 December, 2016

    Edgecam Waveform plays key role in two product launches for Fenn Tool

    Category: Software

Interviews

  • 10 December, 2018

    Mr. Sean Yao, Territory Head, ZWSOFT and Mr. Anubhab Hazra, CEO, CADbro, India, in conversation with CNCTimes

    Category: Software
  • 06 November, 2018

    Mr. Volker Nesenhoner, Chief Executive Officer, OPEN MIND Technologies AG, talks about hyperMILL & Indian Market

    Category: Software
  • 25 September, 2018

    Mr. John Fox, Vice President, Marketing, Mainstream Engineering, Siemens PLM Software Inc, talks about Solid Edge 2019

    Category: Software
  • 28 May, 2018

    Our consistent goal is to continually improve the quality, performance and reliability of our products: Revware Inc

    Category: Software
  • 25 March, 2017

    We aim to be the dependable partner of choice for our customers: Abhijit Kumthekar

    Category: Software
  • 29 January, 2017

    MachineTools.com is exploring possibility to have partnership in India: Stu Carlin

    Category: Software
  • 28 January, 2017

    Mastercam sees a steady growth in the Indian market: Gene Welti

    Category: Software
  • 01 September, 2016

    Cloud capabilities in Solid Edge ST9 provide faster, flexible deployment options: John Fox

    Category: Software
  • 23 June, 2016

    PolyWorks has universal approach with focus on India: Patrick Castera

    Category: Software
  • 05 February, 2015

    Delcam’s vision is in line with leadership goals: Vineet Seth

    Category: Software

Product Showcase

  • 06 July, 2019

    OPEN MIND Expands Functions in High-performance Cutting Module

    Category: Software
  • 14 May, 2019

    Versatile quick-change system for handling weights up to 50 kg

    Category: Software
  • 25 April, 2019

    hyperMILL® 2019.2 at Moulding Expo

    Category: Software
  • 02 April, 2019

    SprutCAM 12 release

    Category: Software
  • 02 April, 2019

    MeasurLink 9 Product Release

    Category: Software
  • 25 March, 2019

    OCTOLite™ Manual Semi-Automatic Inspection System from QVI

    Category: Software
  • 24 April, 2017

    OnCreate3D, First Full Cloud CAM App provides toolpath editing feature

    Category: Software
  • 03 August, 2016

    Single solution to manage thousands of product variants

    Category: Software
  • 16 December, 2015

    Hexagon Manufacturing Intelligence presents the latest release of PC-DMIS

    Category: Software
  • 07 December, 2015

    ANSYS releases new versions of SpaceClaim and FENSAP-ICE

    Category: Software
  • 29 September, 2015

    Renishaw launches new CARTO software solution for calibration systems

    Category: Software
  • 17 October, 2014

    Delcam launches new PowerSHAPE Pro CAD for CAM

    Category: Software

Blogs

  • 11 April, 2017

    “OnCreate3D” First Full Cloud CAM app, introduces Stock Definition, modification and use in rouging toolpaths and many more features.

    Category: Software
  • 31 March, 2017

    HOW TO CREATE MACHINING OPERATIONS AND NC FILE OUTPUT FOR YOUR ONSHAPE MODELS

    Category: Software
  • 03 March, 2017

    Cloud computing – what is it ?

    Category: Software
  • 13 January, 2017

    What is Adaptive control in CNC ?

    Category: Software
  • 05 January, 2017

    2D, 3D and 5-axis Milling – where and how much are they used?

    Category: Software
  • 24 December, 2016

    CNC Milling – 2D, 3D, 5-axis milling

    Category: Software
  • 08 December, 2016

    CNC milling – chip breaking

    Category: Software
  • 28 November, 2016

    Cutting speed vs Feed rate – Milling

    Category: Software
  • 21 November, 2016

    Cutting speed vs Feed rate

    Category: Software
  • 10 November, 2016

    Reducing face milling time

    Category: Software
  • 03 November, 2016

    IOT and Industry 4.0

    Category: Software
  • 07 October, 2016

    Modular vs Quick change tooling

    Category: Software

Videos

  • 12th April, 2021

    WORKXPLORE Video for ‘Client Viewer Export'

    Category: Software
  • 04th March, 2021

    OPTIPOWER – One step added to toolpath Optimization.

    Category: Software
  • 23rd December, 2020

    Planning & Scheduling of Projects in WORKPLAN

    Category: Software
  • 16th December, 2020

    Simulation Analysis

    Category: Software
  • 09th December, 2020

    Variable feed rates & Spindle Speeds for Turning cycle

    Category: Software
  • 01st December, 2020

    RADAN Designer : Unfolding single parts and assemblies

    Category: Software
  • 25th November, 2020

    VISI Electrode

    Category: Software
  • 10th November, 2020

    VISI Flow - Efficient Plastic Injection Moulding Simulation Solution

    Category: Software
  • 22nd October, 2020

    Advanced options for cabinet modifications

    Category: Software
  • 12th October, 2020

    Cabinet Design to Production

    Category: Software
  • 07th October, 2020

    ALPHACAM - Feature based machining

    Category: Software
  • 07th October, 2020

    ALPHACAM - Nesting process

    Category: Software

Showroom

  • 29 March, 2019

    Tool Presetter India

    Category: Software

TESTIMONIALS VIEW MORE

We would like to express our sincere appreciation for your service to us.You have provided us best marketing platform through CNCTimes. We look forward to extending our contract with you for years to ...

Mr.Adil Atar, Ass.Mng.Technical Sales & Service: Precision Machinekraft

Dedication and determination is key to success and CNC Times team is evident to it - FARO Business Technologies (I) Pvt Ltd

Ms. Amrita Gokhale , FARO Business Technologies

Seminar was really very good, please let us know about future seminars. we would like to attend the seminar on "Machining of the material above 60 HRc like titanum"

Roshan Deshmukh, Design Engineer - Ashvini Magnets Private Limited

FOLLOW US

TECHNOLOGY FOCUS

    Machine Tools

    • CNC Lathe
    • Boring Machines
    • Drilling Machines
    • Spark Erosion
    • Wire Cut
    • Vertical Machining Centers - VMC
    • Horizontal Machining Centers - HMC
    • Grinding Machines
    • Gear Cutting Machines
    • Additive Manufacturing - RP
    • Multi-Axis Machines
    • Multi-Tasking Machines
    • Welding Machines
    • Presses
    • Laser Cutting
    • Others
    • IIoT

    Metrology

    • CMM
    • VMM ( Vision Measuring Machines )
    • PCMM ( Portable CMM )
    • Measuring Instruments
    • Probing Technology
    • 3D Scanners
    • Roundness Measurement
    • Surface Roughness Measurement
    • Contour Measuring Machines
    • Others

    Accessories

    • Workholding
    • Toolholders
    • Spindles
    • Coolants
    • Others

    Software

    • CAD
    • CAM
    • CAE
    • ERP
    • Inspection Software
    • Reverse Engineering Software
    • MES
    • Others

    Mechatronics

    • Robotics
    • Automation
    • CNC Controllers
    • Others

    Cutting Tools

    • Turning Tools
    • Milling Tools
    • Grinding Wheels
    • Drilling
    • Others

INDUSTRY VERTICALS

  • General
  • Automotive
  • Aerospace
  • Healthcare
  • Healthcare Engineering
  • FMCG
  • Consumer Durable
  • Defence
  • Electronics
  • Oil & Gas
  • Heritage
  • Heavy Engineering
  • Die & Mold
  • Plastic
  • Footwear
  • Jobshop

POLICIES

  • Payment Policy
  • Terms of Use

PROFILE

  • About us
© 2021 www.cnctimes.com
Developed & Maintained by CNCTimes.com